Yesterday I wrote about the differences in the language used by the Green Party leadership when responding to both the Christchurch terror attack and the LynnMall terror attack.
Today I thought I would have a look at the differences in language between Green List MP Golriz Ghahraman’s official responses to the two terror attacks as she had an awful lot to say about the first terror attack and I was curious to see if she would treat an attack on members of the (white?) West Auckland community the same way.
**Note: we do not know the race of the members of the West Auckland community that were stabbed by the Islamic terrorist as the MSM has chosen to not reveal that information. I suspect it is precisely because he targeted people on the basis of their skin colour that the MSM has kept that information from the public – but my hunch is purely speculative at this stage
Golriz Ghahraman’s Speech in Response to the Christchurch Mosque Terror Attacks Wednesday, March 20, 2019
A-salaam-alaikum Mr Speaker, Our nation’s heart is broken. My heart is broken today. Five days on, as the wound is still fresh, we have comfort in all the love. All over our country. I have seen the outpouring of grief. I’ve stood with communities as we wrapped our arms around one another. We gathered at mosques, we held each other at vigils, we held our little ones a little tighter as we remembered that little Mucad Ibrahim at 3 years old was one of the victims on Friday.
The city of Dunedin ran out of flowers on Saturday. They were all at the mosque. That is the New Zealand which welcomed me and my family when we fled oppression, the risk of torture, after we had lived through war.
I will never forget that love as a nine year old girl coming down that escalator in Auckland airport with my frightened parents. And I want to thank every single New Zealander who held true to our values, of love and inclusion this week. We are on the right side of history. It matters to our frightened communities.
I will never forget that a Syrian refugee family were among the victims of this terror attack. Like my family they escaped the unthinkable and found freedom here. They came here to be safe, they died in Christchurch, NZ.
We owe those victims the truth. This was terrorism. It was committed by white supremacists. Planned at length without police interference. Because white supremacy was not seen as a pressing threat, though the Muslim victims had been.
Although the man who committed the terror happened not to be born here the ideology that lead to this atrocity existed here…ethnic communities, refugees, tangata whenua have been telling us it exists for years. I know it as my daily truth, as a politician perceived to be Muslim, known to be a refugee, I’ve spoken about the barrage of hate I receive online, of gun violence, death threats, rape, calls for shotguns to be loaded. Every minority in NZ knows this truth.
We have to pause, and listen. We can’t pretend this was an aberration from overseas. That would be irresponsible. The truth is that this happened here. And it began with hate speech, allowed to spread here online. History has taught us that hate speech is a slippery slope to atrocity.
We now know that New Zealand needs to address this. The truth is that we, as politicians- and I mean on all sides of this House, are also responsible. There sit among us those who have for years fanned the flames of division in here and out there. Blamed migrants for our housing crisis. There sit among us here who deliberately spread hysteria about the UN Migration Compact.
We know that those words were written on his gun. We’ve pandered to the gratuitous racism by shock jocks on breakfast shows to raise our own profile.No one here is directly responsible for what happened in Christchurch. We are all horrified. But we are now all on notice. We must change the way we do politics here.
Our most vulnerable communities are hurt. We are scared. White Supremacists want us dead. The people at those incredible vigils are watching. They will hold us to account. Their acts of love, their resolve, is the standard we have to hold ourselves to from now on. The world is watching. We have to get this right. We have to demonstrate to the rest of the world that love, peace, and compassion is a far stronger force than the forces of hate and division.
We must be brave as we have the hard conversations we need to have as a country. We must shine the light into the shadows of racism and hatred that exist in pockets of our society. We must weave the incredible outpouring of love for our Muslim and migrant communities that we have seen over the last few days into the enduring fabric of our society.
We have to do this for all the families who have had the lives of loved ones taken from them. We have to do this for little Muscad Ibrahim. Kia hora te marino Kia whakapapa pounamu te moanaAroha atu, aroha mai Tatou ia tatou katoa
Now for Her Statement on the Lynnmall Terror Attack…
Since I could not find an official response to the LynnMall terror attack from Golriz Ghahraman I looked for and found the following unofficial response on her Twitter feed.
Friday’s tragic terror attack must not be used to rush counter terror laws without scrutiny. This has never helped before! Our response must capture the complexity of radicalisation, protect rights, and guard against causing more harm to the most marginalised communities.— Golriz Ghahraman (@golrizghahraman) September 6, 2021
“I worry for the Sri Lankan kids who will go to school on Monday and hear the words “You’re a terrorist”. I worry for Muslim Kiwis who will likely face increased hostility from the public”— Golriz Ghahraman (@golrizghahraman) September 4, 2021
An important piece, must’ve been difficult to write @jehancasinaderhttps://t.co/EkJrubVuWO
We stand in aroha and support for the victims of today’s horrific terror attack at #lynnmall. We will not allow his hate to turn towards our communities of colour or Muslim communities who have suffered so much. Aotearoa is strong and united ?@NZGreens https://t.co/tmG4el9r2c— Golriz Ghahraman (@golrizghahraman) September 3, 2021
Unsurprisingly Golriz is only concerned about the wellbeing of one community regardless of which community was the actual target of the terrorism.
As I revealed yesterday when analysing the Official Green Party leadership’s language, no matter which side of the terror fence Muslims are on they will always be seen as victims by The Green Party.
In her speech in 2019 Golriz said that the politics of division and hate must end. I quite agree. It is well past time that she and other politicians like her who ” fan the flames of division” stopped smearing white people as racist and white supremacists.