Reports the Sir Brian Roche group hasn’t provided any formal advice to the Government in relation to the recent positive Covid-19 cases at the Grand Millennium rightly begs the question, what is the point of the group, National’s Covid-19 Response spokesperson Chris Bishop says.

“In answers to Written Parliamentary Questions Covid-19 Response Minister Chris Hipkins admitted he hasn’t received any formal advice in relation to the Grand Millennium Covid cases, in which it was revealed that a security guard had not been tested for Covid-19 for six months.

“Many companies working at the border have not been using the Government’s border testing register, the register has only just been made compulsory for companies to use, and the Government only started analysing the data on the voluntary register a few weeks ago.

“The cases out of the Grand Millennium and the lack of good governance they have revealed are deeply troubling.

“The Government has blamed everyone but itself for the debacle over the border testing register – from employers, to employees, we even had the unedifying spectacle of the Prime Minister telling Parliament a security guard had lied while the investigation was underway.

“The group led by Sir Brian Roche was supposed to advise the Minister on whether the Government’s response is performing efficiently and effectively and to provide advice on areas that need improvement.

“For the Sir Brian Roche-led group to make any difference the Government should have immediately asked them for advice on how to improve things off the back of the Grand Millennium cases.

“The Government should be making sure such a situation doesn’t occur again by taking the necessary steps to modify and improve its approach.

“The fact it hasn’t asked for advice is staggering and people will rightly be questioning what the point of the group is.”


Parliamentary Written Questions 

Reply 13274 (2021) has been answered 

Portfolio: COVID-19 Response (Hon Chris Hipkins)  

Question: Has he received any advice from the “Independent group to oversee continual  improvement in COVID-19 response” chaired by Sir Brian Roche in relation to the recent  COVID-19 positive cases at the Grand Millennium managed isolation facility; if so, what did it  say; when did he receive the advice; how was the advice communicated to him; and will he  release that advice publicly?  

Reply: In my capacity as Minister for COVID-19 Response, I have not received any formal advice  from the COVID-19 Independent Continuous Review, Improvement and Advice Group in  relation to the recent COVID-19 positive cases at the Grand Millennium isolation facility.  13274 (2021) 

Reply 13273 (2021) has been answered 

Portfolio: COVID-19 Response (Hon Chris Hipkins)  

Question: Has he received any advice from the “Independent group to oversee continual  improvement in COVID-19 response” chaired by Sir Brian Roche in relation to the number of  people reportedly not getting COVID-19 tests when they should be getting them; if not, why  not, and will he seek advice from the group on this issue?  

Reply: The COVID-19 Independent Continuous Review, Improvement and Advice Group (the  Group) has not provided any formal advice in relation to the number of people reportedly not getting COVID-19 tests when they should be getting them. The Group have advised me there is information emerging that indicates some people in surveillance programmes may not be receiving regular testing. The Group further noted that while conclusions cannot be drawn from the data the agency has seen, more research should be done to look at the potential issue. The Group’s focus is on continuous assurance from a system point of view and they are developing their work programme and cadence of reporting to me.  

Please share this BFD article so others can discover The BFD.

This article is a press release that has been published in full and un-edited by The BFD.